Leave a Message
By providing your contact information to Whitney McLaughlin, your personal information will be processed in accordance with Whitney McLaughlin's Privacy Policy. By checking the box(es) below, you expressly consent to receive marketing or promotional real estate communication from Whitney McLaughlin in the manner selected by you. For SMS text messages, message frequency varies. Message and data rates may apply. Consent is not a condition of purchase of any goods or services. You may opt out of receiving further communications from Whitney McLaughlin at any time. To opt out of receiving SMS text messages, reply STOP to unsubscribe. SMS text messaging is subject to our Terms of Use.
Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.
Explore Our Properties
Close view of a cedar and pale-stone home entrance with bronze-framed glazing, granite steps and golden leaves on a white-barked tree.

Is Aspen Getting Cheaper? What the Falling Median Hides About Houses and Condos

In July, Elk Mountain Lodge went to auction. It's a 52-acre compound at 125 Rooney Circle, off Castle Creek Road about 11 miles from town. The Aspen Times reported that the property went under contract at $33.515 million after a peak asking price of $125 million in 2025. The Wall Street Journal reported the same high bid and said the sale was expected to close in about 30 days. A 9News report credited to the Denver Business Journal gave a different winning figure, $35.52 million. As of early October, none of the reporting we found confirmed a recorded closing price.

A gap that large makes headlines, and it fits easily into a story about Aspen prices coming down. The town-level data tells a more specific story, and buyers will find it more useful. The single-family median fell sharply in 2026, mostly because of which houses sold. What changed on the ground is how far closing prices land below asking, and that change applies to houses far more than to condos.

Asking price and closing price drifted apart for houses

The Aspen Board of REALTORS publishes town-level statistics for Aspen. Its newest report covers year-to-date activity through July 2026 and was current as of August 5, 2026. We found no August or September town report posted as of early October, so these are the freshest like-for-like figures available.

Through July, year-to-date Single-family, 2025 Single-family, 2026 Townhouse/condo, 2025 Townhouse/condo, 2026
Sold listings 53 39 58 45
Median sales price $13,250,000 $10,185,000 $3,175,000 $3,400,000
Percent of list price received 94.2% 91.9% 93.8% 95.0%
Days on market until sale 155 255 171 174

Sales of both property types fell by roughly a quarter. From there the two segments diverge. In the first seven months of 2026, single-family sellers received 91.9% of their list price, compared with 94.2% a year earlier, and homes took 255 days to sell, up from 155. Condo and townhouse sellers moved the other way. They received 95.0% of list through July 2026, up from 93.8%, and days on market barely changed.

On a $10 million house, the 2.3-point drop in percent of list received equals about $230,000 more between asking price and closing price than the same house would have seen a year earlier. That gap is what a buyer actually negotiates over, and in Aspen in 2026 it has grown for houses and narrowed for condos.

Why the median dropped 23% while individual homes didn't

The single-family median fell 23.1% through July 2026, from $13.25 million to $10.185 million. The average fell 19.0%, from about $17.2 million to about $13.95 million. A median of 39 sales sits on whichever house happens to land in the middle. When fewer large estates close, that middle point drops, even if no individual home lost that much value.

The 2025 comparison year was unusually heavy at the top. In a September 25 Denver Gazette report on Aspen pricing, a local agent said the jump in the 2025 figures came from sales shifting toward much larger, higher-end homes that skewed the averages, and did not show an increase in the value of Aspen properties. The same logic works in reverse. If 2025 was inflated by a run of big sales, a 2026 with fewer of them will look like a decline even when comparable houses are trading near their earlier levels.

The board flags this risk on its own report. It notes that one month's activity "can sometimes look extreme due to small sample size." July 2026 had nine single-family sales and only two condo and townhouse sales. With samples that small, a single closing on Red Mountain or in the West End can move the median by millions.

Elk Mountain Lodge illustrates the same caution from the other side. It's a 52-acre compound outside town, and one auction result there tells a buyer very little about a West End Victorian or a condo near the gondola.

Supply has been loose for a while, which changes what the discount means

Months of supply shows how long current inventory would last at the current sales pace. For Aspen single-family homes it was 17.9 in July 2026, compared with 18.4 in July 2025. Inventory fell from 126 homes to 109 over the same period. A year and a half of supply is a lot by most measures, but it was already the norm a year ago.

The supply level stayed about the same while the discount at closing grew. Sellers are listing about as much as before. What has changed is how firmly buyers push on price and how long they are prepared to wait before committing.

Condos sit in a tighter position. Townhouse and condo inventory was 87 units in July 2026, compared with 88 a year earlier, and months of supply moved from 10.0 to 11.1. Supply has edged up, but condo sellers are still getting closer to their asking prices than they did in 2025.

The pace picked up over the summer

The first half of 2026 looked worse than the year-to-date totals now do. A broker quoted in the Denver Gazette said Aspen was down 40% in transactions and 50% in dollar volume over the first six months. After summer activity, the year-to-date declines had narrowed to 18% and 20%. The broker attributed the earlier weakness to a poor snow year. The same article describes summer as a stronger selling season than winter. Buyers from hot-weather markets rent for a couple of months and have time to look at property.

For anyone shopping this fall, the July year-to-date figures already include part of that summer recovery. The August and September numbers, once published, will show whether it continued.

What limits how far house prices can fall

The cost of building new limits how far existing house prices can drop. Figures cited in the Gazette article put construction costs at $2,000 to $4,000 per square foot before soft costs. The article also notes that the City of Aspen limits demolition allotments to as few as six per year under current policy, and that Pitkin County adopted an updated land use code in January 2026.

The article gives a sense of what extra square footage costs in town. A transferable development right, or TDR, typically sells for about $850,000. It lets an owner build beyond the 750-square-foot expansion allowed by right.

Taken together, these limits make it very expensive to replace an existing Aspen house with a new one. When a house sells at 91.9% of list, the buyer is still paying far less than it would cost to tear down, get a demolition allotment, and rebuild on that lot. That cost sets a floor under prices, and it helps explain why sellers have accepted wider discounts in 2026 without a broader collapse in values.

Condos are governed by a different rulebook

Condo and townhouse demand in Aspen is closely tied to short-term rental rules. These rules matter more to condo owners than to most house owners.

Aspen Journalism reported in July that city short-term rental permits had declined to 741 as of April 3. Condos accounted for about 70% of Aspen properties holding permits. The city caps permits in residential zones, and permits are generally nontransferable. After the excise tax voters approved in 2022, total taxes on stays come to 17.35% for the lodge-exempt and owner-occupied permit types and 22.35% for the classic permit type. In general, permits do not pass to a buyer automatically. Anyone counting on rental income should look at a condo's permit status early in the process.

The county rules are a separate matter. In unincorporated Pitkin County, 80% of licensed short-term rental properties are single-family homes, according to the same Aspen Journalism report. In August, county commissioners discussed proposed changes reported by the Aspen Daily News:

  • removing the rental-history eligibility test
  • setting permit caps by area
  • reducing fees
  • possibly adding a lodging tax of up to 6%
  • allowing most general permits up to 120 rental nights, with a separate owner-occupied type capped at 30 nights

None of these changes has been adopted. Commissioners asked for more information before discussing code amendments. These proposals apply to properties outside the city limits and do not affect condos inside the City of Aspen.

How the split shapes an offer

All of this points to two different sets of expectations in Aspen this fall.

For single-family homes, the 2026 data through July shows sales closing further below list, after nearly 100 more days on market than a year earlier, with supply that has stayed high for more than a year. A house that has been listed through the summer without selling is the kind of listing where that gap tends to appear. The median price is the least useful figure for judging an individual house. Comparable sales, adjusted for lot size, location, and condition, will say far more.

For condos and townhouses, sellers received a higher share of list price through July than they did in 2025, and the time to sell stayed flat. Expecting a house-sized discount on a condo would not match how that segment has traded in 2026. A condo buyer's questions are more likely to be about short-term rental permit status, the tax rate that applies, and the condition of the building.

FAQ

Did Elk Mountain Lodge sell for $33.5 million? It went under contract after a July 17 auction, with a high bid reported at $33.515 million by The Aspen Times and The Wall Street Journal. Another report gave $35.52 million. We found no reporting that confirmed a recorded closing price or a buyer.

How current are these numbers? The Aspen Board of REALTORS town figures cover activity through July 2026 and were current as of August 5, 2026. As of early October, no August or September town report had been posted.

Do the proposed Pitkin County rental changes affect condos in town? The proposals reported in August apply to unincorporated Pitkin County and had not been adopted. Condos inside the City of Aspen fall under the city's permit system.

If you're weighing an Aspen house against a condo this fall, I can help you see where a specific listing falls against what similar properties have actually closed for in 2026, and what the property would need after closing. Let's Connect with Whitney McLaughlin to start with the comparable sales.

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.

Follow Me On Instagram